February 10, 2026
British Med Journal article-Spine Procedures Often Ineffective
British Medical Journal (BMJ) is an extremely highly respected peer reviewed, evidence based journal, respected across the nation. They scrutinized 132 eligible studies, 81 trials with 7977 patients that explored 13 interventional procedures or combinations of procedures were included in meta-analyses to address the comparative effectiveness of common interventional procedures for chronic non-cancer (axial or radicular) spine pain.
They reported their results: "For chronic axial spine pain, the following probably provide little to no difference in pain relief (moderate certainty evidence): epidural injection of local anaesthetic (weighted mean difference (WMD) 0.28 cm on a 10 cm visual analogue scale (95% CI -1.18 to 1.75)), epidural injection of local anaesthetic and steroids (WMD 0.20 (-1.11 to 1.51)), and joint-targeted steroid injection (WMD 0.83 (-0.26 to 1.93)). Intramuscular [trigger point] injection of local anaesthetic (WMD -0.53 (-1.97 to 0.92)), epidural steroid injection (WMD 0.39 (-0.94 to 1.71)), joint-targeted injection of local anaesthetic (WMD 0.63 (-0.57 to 1.83)), and joint-targeted injection of local anaesthetic with steroids (WMD 0.22 (-0.42 to 0.87)) may provide little to no difference in pain relief (low certainty evidence); intramuscular [trigger point] injection of local anaesthetic with steroids may increase pain (WMD 1.82 (-0.29 to 3.93)) (low certainty evidence). Evidence for joint radiofrequency ablation proved of very low certainty. For chronic radicular spine pain, epidural injection of local anaesthetic and steroids (WMD -0.49 (-1.54 to 0.55)) and radiofrequency of dorsal root ganglion (WMD 0.15 (-0.98 to 1.28)) probably provide little to no difference in pain relief (moderate certainty evidence). Epidural injection of local anaesthetic (WMD -0.26 (-1.37 to 0.84)) and epidural injection of steroids (WMD -0.56 (-1.30 to 0.17)) may result in little to no difference in pain relief (low certainty evidence)."
(Wang X, Martin G, Sadeghirad B, Chang Y, Florez ID, Couban RJ, Mehrabi F, Crandon HN, Esfahani MA, Sivananthan L, Sengupta N, Kum E, Rathod P, Yao L, Morsi RZ, Genevay S, Buckley N, Guyatt GH, Rampersaud YR, Standaert CJ, Agoritsas T, Busse JW. Common interventional procedures for chronic non-cancer spine pain: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised trials. BMJ. 2025 Feb 19;388:e079971. doi: 10.1136/bmj-2024-079971. PMID: 39971346.)
This office partially disagrees with BMJ and reflects on journal club during my Tufts New England Medical Center / Harvard Spaulding PM&R pain specialist residency training. At that time we discussed the fact that the New England Journal of Medicine published in the same edition that prescribed estrogen increased breast cancer in one article and stated in the adjacent article the precisely opposite conclusion that estrogen does not increase breast cancer risks. BMJ is a highly reputable journal but being a physician is an art, nuanced to assess and treat each and every patient individually as a human being. Doctors individualize care and must constantly study to be up to date.
It is recognized that BMJ's results appropriately admonish caution as the spinal cord is exquisitely vulnerable to permanent injury and spine procedures are often ineffective as with all procedures and also often with opioids in terms of safe, legitimate, lawful prescribing. However, doctors' Hippocratic Oaths demand "do no harm" such that even though spine procedures do help many patients, all honest clinicians must study on behalf of their patients. The findings are irrefutable that spine procedures have significant proven risks over the past many, many decades of paraplegia, quadriplegia, hemiplegia, blindness, brain abscess, spinal cord abscess,… and death.
In fact, pain practitioner Gilbert Fanciullo co-published: "I am not convinced that cervical transforaminal epidural steroid injections should be performed. Based on the limited supportive data for this technique, exposing patients to the possibility of these reported devastating complications is hard to justify." Fanciullo's co-publication then stated that even with fluoroscopic guidance for interlaminar epidurals, spinal cord trauma and other catastrophic neurologic outcomes still occur.
(Provenzano DA, Fanciullo G. Cervical transforaminal epidural steroid injections: should we be performing them? Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2007 Mar-Apr;32(2):168; author reply 169-70. doi: 10.1016/j.rapm.2006.06.205. PMID: 17350530.)
Thus, with many patients not appreciating pain relief from spine procedures but also many patients very much appreciating relief, the most reasonable approach is just as nuanced and individualized as with all appropriate medical care. That is to say, spine injections should not be the #1 first line treatment just as with opioids not being first line. This is reasonable as many patients will enjoy far safer pain relief with initial trials with less potentially dangerous treatment.
Seemingly supportive of this office's pain management expertise with nearly four decades of zero prescription opioid overdoses and zero patient harm events with superficial depth NON-axial nerve blocks, Fanciullo also published endorsement of this office's caution in terms of recommended LOW frequency of epidurals relative to far larger numbers of patients with axial spine pain. Fanciullo reviewed 25,479 patients spine and radicular pain and his results were "ESI [epidural steroid injections] were recommended to 2,022 (7.9%) patients. Patients with lumbar pain had ESI proposed 12.6% of the time. Those with cervical and thoracic symptoms had ESI recommended 3.7% and 1.8% of the time, respectively."
(Fanciullo GJ, Hanscom B, Seville J, Ball PA, Rose RJ. An observational study of the frequency and pattern of use of epidural steroid injection in 25,479 patients with spinal and radicular pain. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2001 Jan-Feb;26(1):5-11. doi: 10.1053/rapm.2001.20089. PMID: 11172504.)
When conservative care far from the vulnerable spinal cord does not effect relief, certainly spine procedures are encouraged as long as the clinician is honest and provides full informed consent of the risks for pain practitioner Fanciullo's "devastating complications." As related to a misconduct hearing review, this office's 8/6/2015 expert review of one dangerously incompetent and out of date pain practitioner found that he unconscionably and dishonestly stated that honest and complete informed consent should be abandoned as it "instills fear of epidural steroid injections." Clearly and ethically, patients deserve truth, not concealment of risks such that they can weigh risks vs. benefits as per lawful informed consent.